In the final episode of season one of HBO’s “House of the Dragon,” Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen (Emma D’Arcy) stared straight into the camera, forehead straining and eyes shining with tears. In the wake of her son Lucerys’ (Elliot Grihault) death, wrath was in her eyes, and fans were left on a cliffhanger that promised spectacle, emotion, and an all-out bloody war.
Shockingly, after almost two years since season one premiered, the show is off to another slow start for better, and sometimes for worse.
We begin this new season in the north, with Rhaenyra’s eldest son Jacaerys (Harry Collett) meeting Lord Cregan Stark (Tom Taylor), who tells the prince of the night’s watch and its purpose in keeping the north—and the Seven Kingdoms—safe. As Cregan shows him The Wall, one of the great wonders of Westeros, and begins to tell Jacaerys about what horrors may lay beyond it, they are interrupted by a message: Jacaerys’ brother has been killed.
Throughout the first episode, Lucerys’ death haunts each character on Rhaenyra’s side of the war. From blame being placed on Rhaenys (Eve Best) by Daemon (Matt Smith)—whom he tells could have solved the war if she had simply “Dracarys” in the first season’s penultimate episode—to Rhaenyra who diligently searches the skies and the waters below for a physical confirmation of her son’s death, his memory remains present in the mind of each of his family members who want nothing more than to avenge him.
In King’s Landing, the news of his death brings a sense of uncertainty. Alicent (Olivia Cooke) is disturbed by the killing, but not enough to punish her son Aemond (Ewan Mitchell) who did the act. At the same time, Aemond disguises his guilt with an air of smugness that maintains the guise he puts on for his family. War looms overhead of both factions, and it becomes clear that the grief both Rhaenyra and Aegon (Tom Glynn-Carney) are holding within themselves may end up being their downfalls.
Who is fit to rule the Seven Kingdoms? That is the question that showrunner Ryan Condal seems to be posing for viewers. Is it a grief-stricken mother who, by all accounts, is the rightful heir to the iron throne? Or a young boy who would rather drink himself into a stupor than listen to his advisors? While Condal seems to be adamant that there are no “right” sides to this war, it’s glaringly apparent that actually, there is. Despite this, season two attempts to make a case for each cause, and it’s become clear that the show will try to sway viewers until its final episode.
Gone are the days of villains like Joffrey Baratheon and heroes like Daenerys Targaryen who—up until “Game of Thrones” penultimate episode in Daenerys’ case—remain perfect examples of their archetypes. While George R.R. Martin’s world of ice and fire sees more gray characters than ones who are strictly black and white, for a story like the one “House of the Dragon” is trying to portray, there need to be sides. On those sides, there must be characters for whom casual fans and longtime readers of Martin’s work can root.
The main issue with this season is that the writers don’t even know who they are rooting for. Characters on both sides continue to flip-flop, and in turn, their motivations get murkier by the episode. It’s exhausting to watch at times and frustrating to see such a fantastic first season crumble under the weight of creators who have a disheartening misunderstanding of the story Martin was trying to tell with “Fire & Blood.” At its core, this is a story about a woman being usurped strictly because of her gender, and the dynasty she belongs to subsequently tearing itself apart to keep her away from her birthright.
Despite Rhaenyra being the central focus of both the original novella and the first season of this adaptation, in season two, it almost feels as if she is disappearing from her own show.
Yes, Martin wrote “Fire & Blood” about these two warring factions destroying themselves, but at the heart of it lies a warning. Here, it feels like the writers are only giving us a glimpse of the woman plastered on Times Square billboards. She disappears from the narrative for long periods, which is sometimes due to her overwhelming grief, but it also feels as if the writers aren’t sure who they want Rhaenyra to be. It’s a glaring problem within “House of the Dragon’s” second season, and one that makes the future of this character uncertain.
It’s a shame because Emma D’Arcy is a force to be reckoned with when they are on screen. The actor portrays sorrow so intensely it’s hard to look at them, yet you cannot take your eyes away. As their face scrunches up to try and hold tears at bay, I couldn’t help but think that this is perhaps the best performance in anything related to “A Song of Ice and Fire” since the early seasons of “Game of Thrones.” It’s rare for a talent like this to exist in a performer so early in their career, and their performance gets even better when they share the screen with Matt Smith, who continues to make Daemon one of the most captivating characters in the series.